3667: Disable autobatching of additions and deletions r=irevoire a=dureuill

# Pull Request

## Related issue
Fixes #3664

## What does this PR do?
- Modifies the autobatcher to not batch document additions and deletions, as a workaround to the DB corruption in #3664 



Co-authored-by: Louis Dureuil <louis@meilisearch.com>
This commit is contained in:
bors[bot] 2023-04-12 16:51:13 +00:00 committed by GitHub
commit d59d75c9cd
No known key found for this signature in database
GPG Key ID: 4AEE18F83AFDEB23
2 changed files with 33 additions and 169 deletions

View File

@ -311,18 +311,9 @@ impl BatchKind {
}) })
} }
( (
BatchKind::DocumentOperation { method, allow_index_creation, primary_key, mut operation_ids }, this @ BatchKind::DocumentOperation { .. },
K::DocumentDeletion, K::DocumentDeletion,
) => { ) => Break(this),
operation_ids.push(id);
Continue(BatchKind::DocumentOperation {
method,
allow_index_creation,
primary_key,
operation_ids,
})
}
// but we can't autobatch documents if it's not the same kind // but we can't autobatch documents if it's not the same kind
// this match branch MUST be AFTER the previous one // this match branch MUST be AFTER the previous one
( (
@ -345,35 +336,7 @@ impl BatchKind {
deletion_ids.push(id); deletion_ids.push(id);
Continue(BatchKind::DocumentClear { ids: deletion_ids }) Continue(BatchKind::DocumentClear { ids: deletion_ids })
} }
// we can autobatch the deletion and import if the index already exists // we can't autobatch a deletion and an import
(
BatchKind::DocumentDeletion { mut deletion_ids },
K::DocumentImport { method, allow_index_creation, primary_key }
) if index_already_exists => {
deletion_ids.push(id);
Continue(BatchKind::DocumentOperation {
method,
allow_index_creation,
primary_key,
operation_ids: deletion_ids,
})
}
// we can autobatch the deletion and import if both can't create an index
(
BatchKind::DocumentDeletion { mut deletion_ids },
K::DocumentImport { method, allow_index_creation, primary_key }
) if !allow_index_creation => {
deletion_ids.push(id);
Continue(BatchKind::DocumentOperation {
method,
allow_index_creation,
primary_key,
operation_ids: deletion_ids,
})
}
// we can't autobatch a deletion and an import if the index does not exists but would be created by an addition
( (
this @ BatchKind::DocumentDeletion { .. }, this @ BatchKind::DocumentDeletion { .. },
K::DocumentImport { .. } K::DocumentImport { .. }
@ -674,36 +637,36 @@ mod tests {
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false,None, [settings(false)]), @"Some((Settings { allow_index_creation: false, settings_ids: [0] }, false))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false,None, [settings(false)]), @"Some((Settings { allow_index_creation: false, settings_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false,None, [settings(false), settings(false), settings(false)]), @"Some((Settings { allow_index_creation: false, settings_ids: [0, 1, 2] }, false))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false,None, [settings(false), settings(false), settings(false)]), @"Some((Settings { allow_index_creation: false, settings_ids: [0, 1, 2] }, false))");
// We can autobatch document addition with document deletion // We can't autobatch document addition with document deletion
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, true))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, true))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, true))"###);
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, true))"###);
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, false))"###);
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, false))"###);
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, true))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, true))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None), doc_del()]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, true))"###);
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, true))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, true))"###);
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, false))"###);
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto")), doc_del()]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0] }, false))"###);
// And the other way around // we also can't do the only way around
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, None)]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, None)]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, None)]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, None)]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, Some("catto"))]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, true, Some("catto"))]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, Some("catto"))]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: true, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, true, Some("catto"))]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(true, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: None, operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, None)]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: ReplaceDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(ReplaceDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @r###"Some((DocumentOperation { method: UpdateDocuments, allow_index_creation: false, primary_key: Some("catto"), operation_ids: [0, 1] }, false))"###); debug_snapshot!(autobatch_from(false, None, [doc_del(), doc_imp(UpdateDocuments, false, Some("catto"))]), @"Some((DocumentDeletion { deletion_ids: [0] }, false))");
} }
#[test] #[test]

View File

@ -1869,105 +1869,6 @@ mod tests {
snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "both_task_succeeded"); snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "both_task_succeeded");
} }
#[test]
fn document_addition_and_document_deletion() {
let (index_scheduler, mut handle) = IndexScheduler::test(true, vec![]);
let content = r#"[
{ "id": 1, "doggo": "jean bob" },
{ "id": 2, "catto": "jorts" },
{ "id": 3, "doggo": "bork" }
]"#;
let (uuid, mut file) = index_scheduler.create_update_file_with_uuid(0).unwrap();
let documents_count = read_json(content.as_bytes(), file.as_file_mut()).unwrap();
file.persist().unwrap();
index_scheduler
.register(KindWithContent::DocumentAdditionOrUpdate {
index_uid: S("doggos"),
primary_key: Some(S("id")),
method: ReplaceDocuments,
content_file: uuid,
documents_count,
allow_index_creation: true,
})
.unwrap();
snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "registered_the_first_task");
index_scheduler
.register(KindWithContent::DocumentDeletion {
index_uid: S("doggos"),
documents_ids: vec![S("1"), S("2")],
})
.unwrap();
snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "registered_the_second_task");
handle.advance_one_successful_batch(); // The addition AND deletion should've been batched together
snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "after_processing_the_batch");
let index = index_scheduler.index("doggos").unwrap();
let rtxn = index.read_txn().unwrap();
let field_ids_map = index.fields_ids_map(&rtxn).unwrap();
let field_ids = field_ids_map.ids().collect::<Vec<_>>();
let documents = index
.all_documents(&rtxn)
.unwrap()
.map(|ret| obkv_to_json(&field_ids, &field_ids_map, ret.unwrap().1).unwrap())
.collect::<Vec<_>>();
snapshot!(serde_json::to_string_pretty(&documents).unwrap(), name: "documents");
}
#[test]
fn document_deletion_and_document_addition() {
let (index_scheduler, mut handle) = IndexScheduler::test(true, vec![]);
index_scheduler
.register(KindWithContent::DocumentDeletion {
index_uid: S("doggos"),
documents_ids: vec![S("1"), S("2")],
})
.unwrap();
snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "registered_the_first_task");
let content = r#"[
{ "id": 1, "doggo": "jean bob" },
{ "id": 2, "catto": "jorts" },
{ "id": 3, "doggo": "bork" }
]"#;
let (uuid, mut file) = index_scheduler.create_update_file_with_uuid(0).unwrap();
let documents_count = read_json(content.as_bytes(), file.as_file_mut()).unwrap();
file.persist().unwrap();
index_scheduler
.register(KindWithContent::DocumentAdditionOrUpdate {
index_uid: S("doggos"),
primary_key: Some(S("id")),
method: ReplaceDocuments,
content_file: uuid,
documents_count,
allow_index_creation: true,
})
.unwrap();
snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "registered_the_second_task");
// The deletion should have failed because it can't create an index
handle.advance_one_failed_batch();
snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "after_failing_the_deletion");
// The addition should works
handle.advance_one_successful_batch();
snapshot!(snapshot_index_scheduler(&index_scheduler), name: "after_last_successful_addition");
let index = index_scheduler.index("doggos").unwrap();
let rtxn = index.read_txn().unwrap();
let field_ids_map = index.fields_ids_map(&rtxn).unwrap();
let field_ids = field_ids_map.ids().collect::<Vec<_>>();
let documents = index
.all_documents(&rtxn)
.unwrap()
.map(|ret| obkv_to_json(&field_ids, &field_ids_map, ret.unwrap().1).unwrap())
.collect::<Vec<_>>();
snapshot!(serde_json::to_string_pretty(&documents).unwrap(), name: "documents");
}
#[test] #[test]
fn do_not_batch_task_of_different_indexes() { fn do_not_batch_task_of_different_indexes() {
let (index_scheduler, mut handle) = IndexScheduler::test(true, vec![]); let (index_scheduler, mut handle) = IndexScheduler::test(true, vec![]);